New iPods: The player sizzles, the phone fizzles

Consumer Reports reviews the Apple iPod Nano and new Motorola ROKR and gives their opinion. They say that the Apple iPod Nano lives up to the hype, but that the phone is not ripe. They don't give many details about the Nano, they just mention its got a small sharp screen and syncs with Outlook.

They compare the ROKR to the Sony Ericsson W800 and say its not as good. The W800 has a better camera, can hold more songs if you increase its memory, and has a better bluetooth implementation. On the ROKR you can only listen to music or take calls on a BT headseat, but the W800 lets you do both.